Go back up one level Return to home page Go to next page

Overview of an elegant [1]   solution to the Synoptic Problem


  1. The documents

    The relevant documents are the logia and the gospels of Mark, Matthew and Luke, written in that order, and with each author having had access to a copy of each earlier document. Thus Matthew was a source for Luke, Mark was a source for both Matthew and Luke, and the logia was a source for all three synoptic gospels.

  2. The first gospel

    Mark's gospel was the first written story of the life of Jesus, and the account was adapted and developed by both Matthew and Luke.

  3. The logia

    The logia was an Aramaic collection of sayings attributed to Jesus, known from the testimony of Papias [2] : "So Matthew made an orderly arrangement of the oracles (Gk: 'logia') in the Hebrew [3]   language, and each interpreted/translated according to his ability".

  4. The Double Tradition

    The key to the solution of the Synoptic Problem is to recognize that the Double Tradition [4]   was dual-sourced.

  5. The aphorisms

    A majority of the Double Tradition passages derive from the logia. They contain aphorisms, [5]   most of which Matthew and Luke translated independently into Greek. [6]

  6. Where Luke used Matthew

    A minority of the Double Tradition passages derive from Matthew. They represent places where Luke copied and edited some of Matthew's extensions to Mark, such as the Temptations, the Centurion's Servant, the Unclean Spirit, and the Lament over Jerusalem.

  7. Mark's use of the logia

    Mark generally treated the logia with less respect than Matthew and Luke, omitting about half of its sayings, and amending most of those he used. However among its aphorisms he did retain a few which are not part of the Double Tradition, such as the saying about the camel and the eye of a needle, and the one about giving taxes to Caesar.

Notes

1. The elegance is two-fold. Firstly because this solution combines the best features of the prevailing Two Source Theory together with the best features of one of its main rivals: the Farrer Theory. Secondly because this solution brings to light a document known for centuries as 'the logia' (the sayings of Jesus), but only now successfully reconstructed and shown to have been a majestic piece of first-century Semitic poetry.

2. As quoted by Eusebius. Papias (ca. 60-130 CE) was the bishop of Hierapolis.

3. In Papias' time people who wrote in Greek would often use "Hebrew" to mean either Hebrew or Aramaic.

4. The Double Tradition consists of passages which are common to Matthew and Luke but not to Mark.

5. An aphorism is a short pithy saying.

6. In a few exceptional cases Luke appears to have made use of Matthew's translation.


Go back up one level Return to home page Go to next page